Talk:Oceania: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The song is not by DCD. The audio "proof" is just the audio we already have instead of an alternative performance. It would be a different take if it truly was an earlier performance from 1988. Also they said that Oceania is mentioned on DCD's site when it bluntly isn't. I gave the proof in the previous edits that you reverted. | The song is not by DCD. The audio "proof" is just the audio we already have instead of an alternative performance. It would be a different take if it truly was an earlier performance from 1988. Also they said that Oceania is mentioned on DCD's site when it bluntly isn't. I gave the proof in the previous edits that you reverted. | ||
:The Oceania part at audio on Vocaroo is clearly shorter than what we have on the bootleg CD (like 10-20 seconds), so it can't be the same. Another argument proving that it's from DCD is that the next song after Oceania is Awakening (you can clearly hear it from 20:10 on Vocaroo snippet), just exactly like on the tracklist of MusicBrainz. What comes to DCD site, maybe it's not the official site of DCD, but still it was mentioned on it. --[[User:LB-LM|LB-LM]] ([[User talk:LB-LM|talk]]) 19:18, 17 May 2024 (EDT) | :The Oceania part at audio on Vocaroo is clearly shorter than what we have on the bootleg CD (like 10-20 seconds), so it can't be the same. Another argument proving that it's from DCD is that the next song after Oceania is Awakening (you can clearly hear it from 20:10 on Vocaroo snippet), just exactly like on the tracklist of MusicBrainz. What comes to DCD site, maybe it's not the official site of DCD, but still it was mentioned on it. --[[User:LB-LM|LB-LM]] ([[User talk:LB-LM|talk]]) 19:18, 17 May 2024 (EDT) | ||
:No, it's the exact same audio with the exact same cheers in the background. And just because there is a song called awakening, doesn't mean the song is by DCD. It just means there is another incorrect credit. The Wings - Wild Wonders tape has 10 songs credited to them, but that doesn't mean all 10 are really by Wings. And it's not on the official DCD site, that's what I'm pointing out. The source they are getting their information from is not trustworthy. There is no trustworthy source that states the song is by DCD. -Ziro | |||
Revision as of 18:25, 17 May 2024
The song is not by DCD. The audio "proof" is just the audio we already have instead of an alternative performance. It would be a different take if it truly was an earlier performance from 1988. Also they said that Oceania is mentioned on DCD's site when it bluntly isn't. I gave the proof in the previous edits that you reverted.
- The Oceania part at audio on Vocaroo is clearly shorter than what we have on the bootleg CD (like 10-20 seconds), so it can't be the same. Another argument proving that it's from DCD is that the next song after Oceania is Awakening (you can clearly hear it from 20:10 on Vocaroo snippet), just exactly like on the tracklist of MusicBrainz. What comes to DCD site, maybe it's not the official site of DCD, but still it was mentioned on it. --LB-LM (talk) 19:18, 17 May 2024 (EDT)
- No, it's the exact same audio with the exact same cheers in the background. And just because there is a song called awakening, doesn't mean the song is by DCD. It just means there is another incorrect credit. The Wings - Wild Wonders tape has 10 songs credited to them, but that doesn't mean all 10 are really by Wings. And it's not on the official DCD site, that's what I'm pointing out. The source they are getting their information from is not trustworthy. There is no trustworthy source that states the song is by DCD. -Ziro